Inhaltsverzeichnis

4.2 Work on site

As long as it involves simple repair work that we ourselves carry out, supported by suggestions from the manufacturer, no special problems appear which we cannot overcome with sufficient technical know how.

The thought, however, of having to repair a car in a standard garage without assembly pit, equivalent to an overhaul (main inspection) of a gas turbine, can be a challenge even to a technician. Narrow space facilities, not ready at hand rigs and lacking online help, through direct consulting with colleagues, make work, that is not a problem in the shop, a special task. The stand by operator is not always considered helpful.

The more we know about the specialties and risks of this work, the easier it is to avoid problems.

Typical task on site is inspection work already mentioned in the previous Chapter 4.1. The operator needs to carry out maintenance work such as cleaning and /or washing of the compressor ( "Ill. 4.2-1.1"), according to the manufacturer’s (OEM) instructions. Precisely in this process, some things have to be considered. If the compressor shows a clear deterioration (see manufacturer’s details) not connected to a malfunctioning of the bleed valves, a visual examination of the inlet area should be undertaken. If there are signs of oil residue, the source of this contamination should be detected.

If found, one must provide remedies. It is important to keep in mind, that modern compressors are already strongly influenced by impurities that are not recognizable at first sight (e.g., oil film). An examination with clean paper can be helpful. When in doubt, if the manufacturer does not suggest otherwise, a cleaning of the compressor should be undertaken. A modern computer aided engine monitoring (gas path analysis, Chapter 5.1) allows to identify the optimal point of time to wash the engine depending on the compressor data ( "Ill. 4.2-1.2").

The cleaning of the compressor ( "Ill. 4.2-1.1" and "Ill. 4.2-2") can follow in different ways, but always with reference to manufacturer’s instructions. The kind of cleaning with abrasive dry materials and/ or liquid wash solutions depends on the type and consistency of the impurities and deposits to be removed (Chapter 3.1.2.2). Accordingly, one decides the cleaning procedure and the washing or cleaning material together with the amount and method of work. Compressors that run under especially unfavorable conditions must be more frequently cleaned. Here devices offered by the manufacturer (OEM) have to be available.

If the blades show dry, hard deposits, one cleans with light abrasive dry materials such as nut shells, rice shells or polish powders. During cleaning with abrasive materials, in case the manufacturer does not give any details, one has to definitely take care that no erosion sensitive coatings are damaged in the compressor ( "Ill. 3.1.2.4-4"). These are, e.g., organic paint on blades and casings soft abradables and unprotected Mg and Al materials. In case of doubt, ask the OEM.

For oily and sticky deposits one recommends liquid wash solutions. Even here, only permitted original media from the manufacturer should be used ( "Ill. 4.2-1.1"). Not only the direct main gas passage is to be considered, but also the air removals/bleeds and tubes belonging to it, measurement systems and units. If, the producer demands it, there are, e.g., bleed tubes in the lower compressor casing half, to be so treated that the wash solution can indeed emerge, but is not further transported by the tubes. If it is foreseen in the design, tubes are to be drained at fluid drainages. All drainage tubes are to be opened according to manufacturers instructions. If demanded, openings for pyrometer, fire detectors or similar probes are to be sealed.

As usual, the wash process starts with a sufficient water cleaning of 5 to 10 minutes at low compressor speeds. This wash process must balance the drying effect of the air current. One has to pay attention that all air meeting surfaces are entirely wet. Here, variable inlet guide vanes must be entirely opened. The injection of the aqueous cleaning solution follows with a suitable device in the area of the blade roots during the slow down of the rotor, up to a speed with which the cleaning solution cannot be transported through the entire compressor. Finally, a sufficient soaking time during static makes possible that the stuck coatings soften and loosen. Those can be removed during low speed, through a further double- so- long water flushing, together with the cleaning solution remnants. An examination of the emitted water impurities, e.g., can throw light on the origin and cause. Aimed measures against the causes of air impurities are made possible. After washing, the engine should run further for 20 minutes in order to dry. An especially good cleaning effect can be reached through a follow up cleaning process with dry abrasive media during the first operation with low power.

Depending on conditions such as accessibility, size of engine and available infrastructure, extensive maintenance and repair work is carried out on site by the technicians of the manufacturer or a firm recommended by him. Here, however, it is necessary that the operator himself or a technical consultant is present. It is important that the operator forms his own impression of the condition of the engine. According to experience, decisions with a certain margin are necessary. He is then questioned on limited further usage of operation influenced components.

One assumes the successful cooperation of manufacturer, operator and consultant. This is even more feasible the more the consultant is recognized by the manufacturer (OEM). As overhaul locally often does not have the optimum conditions (e.g., accessibility) for personnel, one has to proceed with care, thoroughness and expertise.

 Illustration 4.2-1.1

"Illustration 4.2-1.1": The washing of the compressor (Lit.4.2-2 and Lit.4.2-3) must then be considered when the performance of the engine up to a given point (A) drops. Characteristics of a deteriorated compressor efficiency are critically raised gas temperatures, respectively, higher fuel consumption.Depending on the outer influences (partly air impurities) or availability, there are diverse time intervals up to point (A). Mainly because of this, there are no definite given time distances. One has to examine whether the performance decline is, in the main, due to compressor fouling (deposits, roughening up through coating on the blades) or not. It is necessary to make certain of this because other components like labyrinths or the turbine blades can also be the cause for the long time trend in curve C that shows the performance decline of the engine. They don’t benefit from one washing process A visual inspection of the inlet area and, if need be, a borescope inspection conveys sufficiently definite information. One can assume that deposits of oil and salt are removable through washing and the technically possible high compressor performance (B) can be attained again. If one does not wash the compressor, a deterioration along curve D is to be expected. Not removable is roughness originating through corrosion or erosion on the base material of the blades. Here, if need be, only an exchange of blades helps. Through cleaning, different means, depending on the type of deposits, can be used alone or in combination. These are:

  • Light, dry abrasive media such as nuts or rice shells
  • Liquid media such as water- cleaning material mixtures.

An example for a cleaning process is in Lit. 1.1- 6 according to experience, the most effective method soaking with belated washing. Here, the shut down of the engine with a sufficient cooling time is necessary. The washing is done under low revolution of the compressor with the starter. Higher revolution, with considerable airflow, which could wash the loosened contaminations to the hot parts, is to be avoided strictly. Subsequently, the specified amount of waterwashing solution is sprayed into the compressor and soaked for 3 to 4 minutes. The subsequent washing process follows with a gush of clean water. It is of especial importance that an effective drainage of impure cleaning fluid is guaranteed.

The use of light abrasive media is ill advised if there is a danger that, in the gas path, paints on the blades and casings or abradables ( "Ill. 3.1.2.4-4") can be damaged. Even where there are risks of contaminating the oil system (oil filter inspection, Chapter 3.5), abrasive cleaning material is to be avoided.

In wash methods that use kerosene /water mixtures during idle running and burn, one has the advantage of short shut downs in which the engine is not available; there is, however, the danger that the impurities succeed in infiltrating the hot parts and there induce huge long term failures through high temperature corrosion. To this also counts the sulfidation ( "Ill. 3.4-2" and "Example 4.2-1").

The exclusive use of manufacturer suggested media is naturally to be followed. Alternative material, even if it is apparently identical with the given written media must be explicitly allowed by the manufacturer.

Precisely because the cleaning of the compressor is a necessary routine, it is to be guaranteed that the cleaning process follows according to rules. It is suggested (Lit.4.2-3) that the manufacturer details and rules. The course of work should be written down clearly and hung up for all to see during work. This is related to

  • cleaning media,
  • measurements to protect hardware and
  • personnel.

It has been shown that the practical experience during cleaning, in connection with the documented attained performance improvement, is a pre requisite for the operator to reach optimum results.

 Illustration 4.2-1.2

"Illustration 4.2-1.2": (Lit 4.2-5): Today it is possible with the help of a modern computer aided engine monitoring (gas path analysis, chapter5.1) to optimize the point of time for the washing of a compressor. Beyond that the deterioration of other components can be considered.

The diagram is shown at the display of the monitoring system. As criteria servs the drop of the earnings of the plant. The example counts for a plant of medium performance size.

It can be seen, that the highest saving potential for the washing is already after ca. 1000 operation hours instead 2000 hours. In one year the saving potential equals the range of a family home.